Jardamuth, I don't see anything you've said that I disagree with. Like I said, your setup will surely be better than mine, and I don't mind saying that AT ALL. And I'm not saying its a negative thing that your setup will be fairly unique do to cost, and requirements that extremely few can handle. What's the "off the shelf cost of a billet wheel, titanium turbine wheel evo turbo with custom turbine wheel lightening ? I'm not asking what it cost you, or even what it would cost me... I am saying what would it cost retail ? Now... That's not even to start the part about a custom one-off twin scroll manifold. Retail would be, what? $1000-$1200-$1400 for a one-off ?
So I'm agreeing with you on everything. The difference is cost.
You are def right on high boost, high back pressure small turbo's. Like everything, There is a trade off. Nothing escapes the trade offs. Your setup would not escape the cost trade off. The cyborg does not escape the back pressure trade off. And my volvo based turbo/adaptor plate will not escape trade off's either. For instance... I'm not selling it because it would cost as much as a ATP big turbo kit. But for me, its a middle ground to all trade offs. The cost ? About $2400 all included ( coolant/oil lines, adaptor plate, cnc comp housing machining, turbine wheel, upgraded bearings, downpipe, new inlet setup, etc etc ). The back pressure? Surely won't come close to a 9cm housing with a TD05 turbine wheel, but it should still be much improved over the 2cm-3cm stock turbine housing, as well as a 13mm/14mm up size in turbine wheel size ( not to mention its a greddy design 9-blade ). Lag ? The small-sided turbine housing and the smaller frame turbine wheel should help with lag, while I expect an increase, I don't expect a ton.
Ok compressor wheel... Ya got me. Lol. The 23T is big. And it does favor flow. Truth is.... I was looking at the options and it was cheap for me to go 19T or 23T as the they were CNC ready. The 20T is what I kinda wanted, but the program was not written and it was going to have to be machined by hand, which was no issue, but it added to the cost at the time. So I went with the 23T. 2.4L srt4 caliber's make about 350-365whp on a TD04HL with a 20T ( stock ). We have 30% less engine, but VE on our side, so I figured my 320-330whp goals were in line with a 20T. The 23T just meant I maybe able to meet those goals without as much boost pressure, which honestly, the focus and fiesta seem to want a ton of boost to make power. I was shocked when I first learned ATP needed 28-28psi from a GTX2867 to make a 12.40 pass on slicks. And 340whp.
The mis-matched sizing of the compressor wheel vs the turbine is nothing new to me. I know its not perfect turbo charger design to do it that way, and that's why I'm not a fuel snob, lol. E85 and methanol are non-optional to me. Octane can over come that issue. Again, I'm agreeing with you. In a perfect world with perfect design and perfect sizing, you can do great things with normal fuel and tuning. But go ask someone that just bought a new lexus what "the pursuit of perfection" COST, lol.
I can't think of a better suited turbo, a better suited turbine housing size, a better suited comp wheel for what your looking at, or a better design than the twin scroll. But like I said, I can't afford an one-off custom twin scroll manifold (I did look at using a chevy cobalt sS turbo btw ). So that takes twin scrolls off the table. Leaves me with dsm style TD05's or costly garrett options. Non-twin scroll, non-titanium turbine wheeled TD05's, I feel like. Would have too much lag. That leaves me with really odd ball VF turbo's, and the ones I'd want come on rare type STi models that will bolt onto non-STi cars, which drives the price up.
That leaves the 30 year old TD04 series.
Two factory readily available turbine housings. Smaller and small, lol.
3 (maybe 4) turbine wheel options. A good sized readily available volvo comp housing that has a good sized AR, and integrated BOV/diverter, which I can actually buy an off the shelf bolt on anti-surge compressor housing for if I need to. And like I said... I can buy the turbo off the shelf for $850 shipped ( with the anti-surge comp housing ).
If you asked me to trade all my parts for yours, I would in heart beat, lol. But... If I can make 290whp with a 2-3cm2 turbine housing and a 32/38 turbine wheel and the tiny comp housing with a big wheel machined in, then... Adding 30whp from the changes seems like I'm prob not asking for too much...
External wastegate...
#1 its been proven many times external gates do better job at just about everything a wastegate can do. Lower EGT's, reduce the amount of flow into bottle necks ( the outlet on the stock manifold, before porting is 1 3/8" in dia !! ), and more recently, I've found the externals flexibility to be very convenient when fighting back pressure that will just physically over come wastegate springs.
But as it pertains to the volvo turbo setup, its simple.... Its simple. No building brackets and adjusting wastegate arms and clocking compressor housings to match the turbine arm. The external gate would be used for its power advantage anyway, but keeping the adaptation of the turbo simple is a big one. I like the dump ( it really does suck ass on a stock stock turbo though ).
If your only wanting 275whp, then keeping the stock intercooler is def going to help you keep the power down, lol. Its not a bad flowing cooler, but it sucks for cooling. Your turbo won't be kicking out as much heat as a stock style turbo of course, but at 25psi from any turbo is going to make SOME heat. You can remove it from the tune, but the stock ECU is VERY sensitive to heat. And.... I just remembered your in Canada, lmao. I think anyway. Ok... Maybe you'll be ok, lol. I saw 82 degrees at 10:30pm a few nights ago here in FL, so our climates are pretty different.
I just wanted to ask about the water to air thing. People how have it, love it. People that don't, have either never had it or refer to 25 year old systems that were not nearly as modern it efficient. Clearly a bad choice for road racing etc, but for drag racers, its pretty awesome.
Well will see what the 23T does though... Worst case? I sell it for what I have in it, and buy a 20T and another comp housing for the same cost. I'm out a rebuild kit and a VSR balance, lol. I'd rather go too small first on the turbine housing to keep lag at bay and too big on the comp so I don't run out. If the car chokes at high RPM, its $150 for a interchangeable 7cm turbine housing. If it surges or lags too much, I can still go back to a 20T. The versatility of the TD04HL really is its strength too.
PS: def no offense to any flaws in my TD04HL setup you bring up
I know its not perfect. But it is a step forward I think. And I hope you don't think I'm being a pita, promise not trying to be. I love everything about the setup that you are building for you.
You inspired me to bring this back to life, so I owe ya that
http://www.fiestastforum.com/forum/threads/5450-Not-for-sale-turbo-upgrade?goto=newpost